Monk Subdivision - Laying Track & Summer Vacation

Progress has been slow but steady on the Monk Subdivision this summer due to a long road trip on Quebec North Shore, Manicouagan, Labrador, Newfoundland, Nova Scotia and New Brunswick. Some real classic trains were witnessed without being scheduled into the program, which made it a nice serendipitous discovery. More on that in a future post.

Otherwise, I have adopted a 1-hour per day work schedule. It's long enough to progress while keeping my mind sharp and not compromising on quality. No idea about when I will complete the entire loop, but I'm far enough that I can run a train from Armagh to Langlois.

As a matter of saving some money and not encouraging overconsumption in my hobby, I've been reusing old Peco track from the previous layouts. Some had been painted, none ballasted. Good sections are reused, bad ones discarded. It's all about ensuring a smooth and reliable geometry for mechanical and aesthetical enjoyment of trains.

I'm working slowly, but steadily, following that old army motto of "slow is fast". As an example, I used masking tape to implement superelevation in my curves. That tape is a little bit unreliable when you stretch it around curved lines. Some was simply ungluing itself due to tension in the tape. My trick is now to lay it in place and cut it later with my hobby knife at 3-4 inches intervals. It removes all the tension and makes sure things stay in place.

Day by day, the loop is closing

It's a little bit weird to speak about so little progress, but at the same way, it demonstrates another point. I generally considered these steps to be technical hurdles to overcome as far as possible to reach the real hobby (paint, ballast, scenery, structures, etc.). With the slower pace I implemented in my life and the reduction of useless time spent online, these less savory steps are now the hobby itself. Laying track carefully is a mind soothing process and an exercise in precision. There is joy in doing that just for the sake of doing it.

Also, having finally discarded a lot of my big dreams - or should I say, delusions - it's much easier to reach to the basics that counts. I'm no longer focussing in laying all the tracks or wiring in one go, having the staging yard figured out right now is basically irrelevant, even the sidings are. As long as that loop of track is built in such a way it can be refined, expanded and modified, the main goal is reached. The rest is just gravy when the current steps will be done.

A small train is enough to give it life...

I used to be extremely nervous about having it all figured out with the layout, down to the type of screws holding the fascia in place. It's all irrelevant. It led to two undesirable outcomes: the accumulation of a lot of stuff thought to be required to "build the layout and motivate me" and worst, the loss of motivation when the proof of concept was going to far. Over the years, I have found out that projects I plan in minute details reach that point where my mind has built the thing in virtual in my mind. It has been figured out and made "real". Under such circumstances, building the real life layout is just a repetition of what happened on paper and in my head. No challenges, no fun, nothing... It's just a sterile repetition. On the other hand, if the planning process gets the basics done but don't go to deep into the details, my brain still has many motivating problem solving opportunities to keep interest high.

At this point in my life, I'd rather build than dream. Monk Subdivision proved me since early this year that making mistakes in that hobby isn't the end of everything and it's generally a matter of spending one evening correcting the situation.

I can't promise when trains will run on that loop, but I'm already having my fun making my mock passenger train longer and longer as flextrack is added everyday!

Monk Subdivision - More Roadbed

 As I reassemble the splines in a slightly improved location, I have to make a few adjustments. The original splines were built when, for a short while, I envisioned to have the station in the foreground and the team track in the background for visual interest. It was a fascinating idea, but I left it alone because the foreground buildings would be a real nuisance during operation, having the team track far away behind the traffic was not optimal and the most intricate facades of the each structure would be invisible, which would be... self defeating.

This change of plan means that the outer left curve in Armagh (West) was build with some compromises due to being a passing track but the inner curve was the right radius. I cut the spline where both the main and passing track had constant radius to remove the discrepancy. To save on material, I cut away the funky old passing track easement to the turnout and only kept the inner portion that had the right 42" radius with a large sweeping easement to the turnout.

On the right corner (East), it was just a matter of matching splines

That salvaged piece of spline was then reattached to the outer track, making a beautiful constant 42" radius for the mainline, which was always the goal.

In the station area, the old splines fit perfectly

I could have saved myself some troubles and relaid the splines from scratch, but that would have meant to buy another sheet of MDF, rip it into strips and build a new series of splines. The recycling option was interesting in the measure I got my desired radius without compromising on the geometry. If such a compromise would have been required, I would have built new from the ground. Track geometry is the place where half-baked efforts and cheapskate strategies never pay of.

Swapping the outer spline for the inner spline in the right corner

Monk Subdivision - Reinstalling the Roadbed

After rebuilding the bridge and adjusting it a bit, it was time to finally reinstall the roadbed aka the splines. I had carefully cut them in sections for storage a year ago to make it easier to rebuild the layout. Unfortunately, I recalled I had buil them according to a different track geometry. 2 years ago, I had in mind to have the station in the foreground and the passing track near the backdrop. However, plans have reverted back to having the depot facing people in the aisle.

A mockup always help to raise your spirit!

It shouldn't take too much work to adapt the splines since the curve radii are corrects. However, I still had to build from scratch the pesky S-curve entering the staging after Lake Therrien. This is probably the most tricky area of the layout. Since I want to run passenger cars and large steamers, I have no choice but make sure the straight transition is over 13 inches and that my curves all have a generous easement.

The track leaving the staging is a 28" radius. I wish I could use a large one, but there is a limit to what can be achieved with the staging. With this tight geometry, not mistakes can be made. So, instead of build the spline right on the layout with a part inserted into the wall and no way to really figure out the radius, I decided to draw a perfect template on a sheet on plywood, drive locating nails at regular intervals and use that as a tool to build the MDF spline. When done, I installed it temporarily and checked the alignment using Kato Unitrack curved tracks. Mind you, I was less than 1/4" out of alignment in the staging room, meaning it was well within building tolerances.

Gluing some cork before installation

Before installing the spline, I glued some cork at the end to ensure I could align the roadbed with the fiberboard in the staging. Installing the spline was a child's play, using some cardboard template to make sure the alignment was perfect.

Installed and ready to glue

All in all, this step proved to be much easier than anticipated, which was a great relief. But it also made me think about the future of the layout, my level of energy and my desire to run trains in a smooth and simpler fashion.

Reverting back to a saner and simpler staging concept

At the end of the day, my philosophy has been rehashed and tested again and again in this blog. Vince Valley just cemented my hatred of complicated wiring, how this stuff can take all the joy from the room. It also thought me the chances I will operated complicated scheduled trains are very scarce. For that reason, I removed the complicated crossover that made it possible to reverse trains. Sure, it was excellent on paper, but execution was complicated, made DCC and DC use incompatible and was a source of derailment even in the best conditions. I decided to reduce the number of available tracks, get rid of the troublesome curved turnout and have a nice and simple staging yard. Sure, trains won't be reverse, but I also have enough loco and rolling stock to stage enough trains in both directions to be happy. Wiring will be simpler and if I ever decided to do some automation, things will be far more user friendly.

Monk Subdivision - Bridge Collapse

While installing the last piece of backdrop this evening, I shut the door off while cutting a piece of MDF in the workshop. I heard the distinct noise of a wood stick falling on the concrete floor. My brain immediately knew what it meant. I may have missed the loud noise made by it due to my ear protectors, but only ONE stick could have produced that highly recognizable noise. It was the lift bridge that collapsed after the retaining stick had fallen due to vibration.

For a few weeks, I wanted to make a stick with anti-slip rubber ends before building a proper stopping mechanism. I failed to implement it for various trivial reason and there, the bridge was down. Given the falling height and the bridge weight, I knew the damage would be substantial.

The lip shattered and took away the spline and abutment with it

The lip exploded, including the bridge abutment and the piece of spline glued to it, shattering wood under the stress of screws. On the hinges side, their wooden support unglued themselves while the 3/4 inch plywood forming the structure splintered like cardboard. The bridge itself was no longer horizontal, but sank down noticeably and the backdrop jammed itself on the rest of the layout. It was a mess.

I must have been quite tired because I calmly assessed the situation and started to dismantle the hinges to relieve some stress. Moving the bridge out of the doorway required quite a lot of strength. It was jammed as if someone had driven it with a sledgehammer.

Plywood was badly damaged at the hinges where the shock was absorbed

Fortunately, the mechanical parts, electrical dowels and hinges were intact albeit laying all over the place. The resin abutment, thought shattered, could be repaired because it broke in three large pieces. No missing shards and the weathering job wasn't affected.

I carefully cleaned the splintered pieces of wood, removing the screws and loose wood fibers. I then reglued everything in place, carefully filling the fissures with carpented glue and making sure everything was square and tight with many clamps. After 30 minutes, almost everything was repaired. Another hour will be required tomorrow to reinstall the hinges supports, the spline and the electrical dowel at the far end.

The abutment broke, but didn't shatter... fortunately

Until I build a safer stopping mechanism, I won't reinstall the lift bridge. I knew it was a liability and I'm lucky the damages weren't fatal.

With that said, the backdrop is almost all in place and sanded down. It will require some putty work after primer, but so far, the result is good. I didn't expect it would be so challenging, but truth to be told, it is! I still need to address a weird corner though. Can't wait to paint the powder blue sky and the Appalachian landscale. It will means that I'm finally ready to reinstall the splines, lay the track and wire them. Something that I've been waiting for more than 5 years.

Monk Subdivision: Circling the Circle

Work on the layout has progressed tremendously over the weekend. Small but crucial tasks made it possible to get the benchwork in place and firmly attached to the stone wall. I now have an almost complete shelf all around the room.

If you have followed the building saga of Monk Subdivision, you know the original benchwork was independent from the stone wall and self supported by a pair of legs and braces. This arrangement had several pitfalls, the more severe being its flimsy nature. It was 16 feet long and wobbling a lot. Another issue was the legs and braces that took a lot of space while providing very little stability. So, this time, steel shelf brackets were mounted on 2x4 attached on the stone wall with concrete screws. I thought it would be a nightmare to drill that wall made of rubble, but it worked very nice and in about 3 hours, all the benchwork was back in place.

 

Finding the real alignment on such an imperfect wall was the big challenge, not the work itself. After some pondering, we decided to install the already assembled benchwork in place, in the right alignment and mounted on temporary legs. Using a long aluminium straightedge, we made sure it was perfectly aligned. 2 x 4s were screwed on the benchwork, then shims were installed to fit the uneven wall. Everything was solidly fixed, painted and brackets installed.

The result is a surprisingly strong and stable shelf. The ergonomics are also much better than the original installation. I may have been set back by a year and a half, but honestly, it pays off. I also decided to make the backdrop 24” high for better photography. Armagh is the main focal point and I prefer a scene that surrounds you.

The next steps will be to close the little 24” long gap in the benchwork, then install the MDF backdrop and paint it. At this point, I will be ready to reinstall the original splines I had carefully cut and stored. Having carefully disassembled the original layout helped to save a lot of rebuilding time. If everything goes well, I could be able to glue the roadbed, install track and do a temporary wiring job in the next few weeks. Without pressure, I would like to be able to run trains around the room by the end of June, which is my main goal with that project.

Benchwork back in place, except the little gap at left

As you have probably observed, I changed my mindset to progress instead of perfection. Good track work, good benchwork, step by step implementation, possibility to go back and improve. I was originally stalled by wanting every steps to be finalized and perfect before moving forward. It doesn’t work. I still don’t know how I will address the staging area turnout issues and crossover, but I know I can still use it as long as 1 track is functional. Others will follow later when and if they are required. Wiring will be minimal then improved according to my empirical needs and not my list of “nice to have”. At the end of the day, a moving train on a loop beats an uncompleted exciting vision. That said, I make sure each steps I do will ensure I can improve and implement more things in the future. In that sense, I'm really glad to have streamlined that projects to a single track mainline with a passing track. It takes out of the window so much hassle, misery and complexity.

As an example, I will start with Peco turnouts with their spring-loaded throw bars. Sure, the holes will be drilled and the frog wire solder at installation. But Tortoise, complex wiring and signals will come later, when the basics stuff is in place and troubleshooted. I guess getting older makes me more impatient to run my trains, yet more pragmatic in what I can achieve.